 CU Amiga The best game of '97 |
 CU Amiga Superstar 93% |
| "A groundbreaking game" |
|
 Amiga Format 92% "Myst is intriguing, addictive and thoroughly gorgeous to look at" | |
| Amiga Times 97% The best game of 1997 |
Fun Time 94% The best game of 1997 |
| Australian Amiga Gazette 97% | |