From myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu Tue Jan 25 18:50:16 1994
Received: from nak.berkeley.edu (nak.Berkeley.EDU [128.32.136.21]) by CSOS.ORST.EDU (8.6.4/8.6.4) with ESMTP id SAA02362 for <ridgwad@CSOS.ORST.EDU>; Tue, 25 Jan 1994 18:50:13 -0800
Received: from uclink.berkeley.edu by nak.berkeley.edu (8.6.4/1.40)
	id SAA07873; Tue, 25 Jan 1994 18:50:11 -0800
Received: from localhost by uclink.berkeley.edu (8.6.4/1.33(web)-oc3)
	id SAA19462; Tue, 25 Jan 1994 18:43:14 -0800
Date: Tue, 25 Jan 1994 18:41:22 -0800 (PST)
From: Alexis David Dinno <myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu>
Subject: Amiga Laptop Quest Report #1 (fwd)
To: ridgwad@CSOS.ORST.EDU
Message-ID: <Pine.3.07.9401251822.A18432-e100000@uclink.berkeley.edu>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII
Status: R






 
disclaimer: Look, you all ride the net, some of 
you've probably read Focault's Pendulum, you
KNOW that ANYONE can be misinformed.  I've 
tried to put together what seems to be the most
accurate picture of the Amiga Laptop in 
Contemporary Society.  Don't sue me.
 
 
Amiga Laptop Quest Report I
 
Hello there oh ye faithful!
 
Thanks for all your interest and contributions
which have made this quest possible.  First let me
say one thing: as far as I can tell Ami portables
have existed, do exist and will continue to do so
(though I might halt at grow and flourish).
 
The undertaking of this project initially started
on bulletin boards local to the Amiga's birth
place in the San Francisco Bay Area for the
purpose of turning my A500 into a laptop portable
(I recently upgraded to an A3000).  I hopped onto
the internet and discovered a wealth of interest
from many people in issues relevant to our Holy
Grail: the laptop Ami.  The recent shape of my
efforts has been directed toward the larger
question of ANY Ami laptop.
 
An abundant wealth of response has prompted me to
organise this information into several sections:
     -The Whys of an Amiga Laptop
     -The Existence of such Beasts
     -The Involvement (or not) of C=
     -The Hacks
         -Hurdles
         -Current Projects
     -The Future
 
You all would not believe the ammount of crap I 
had to sift through when ASCII dumping from the
likes of comp.sys.amiga.hardware to my text
editor.  The sheer ammount of info has been 
enourmous (and much appreciated lest I appear
ingracious).  In order to facilitate the 
edification of the Ami SIG, I will be posting
and mailing only this highly edited file (and
ones like it in the future).  However, I will be
making the net, mail, and board transcripts 
available via FTP site.  This is so that we can
focus directly on the most pertinant information
and progress toward the general accessability of
laptop Ami's for those who so desire them.
 
Fast, and open communication has been the key to
this quest's initial success.  I will continue to
provide e-mail updates for those who wish to 
contact me via e-mail at:
 
myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu
 
Furthermore, I will attempt to provide a list of
individuals who wish to work together on actually 
developing laptops.  This list will be by 
requested invitation only (that is only if one so
desires and e-mails me about it).
 
Alright on to the report.
 
THE WHYS OF THE AMIGA LAPTOP/PORTABLE
Why portables?  In general, many users find that
their computing needs or applications do not
need to be limited by the location of their desks.
We like to write notes on the train, plot graphs
in physics class, and in my case, use MIDI
sequencers in places other than my own home.  
 
For some these needs can be met by the use of
commercially available laptops such as ATs or 
powerbooks or even HP calculators.  Data can often
be uploaded or translated from one system to 
another.  In such a case the available portables 
may serve well.  But for others among us, only an 
application of laptop Amiga software will allow 
us to perform the task at hand in a way which
harmonizes with our other computing lives.  Still 
others may want a portable Amiga only, one's game
system, or flight or road trip planner/organizer.
And finally, there are those of us who desire the
use of Amiga hardware/software packages to perform
tasks unique to Ami, wich have never been 
portable.  One such notion is the 'on the road 
video editing workstation' - an Ami portable, with
a video slot and a toaster.  Perhaps there is even
the glamor of the idea 'my own DON'T PANICK clad
electronic book.'
 
While we are certain that this Ami laptop beast
comes in many forms, all research to date suggests
that there are many limitation and/or hurdles to
their creation.  An important consideration for 
those in search of the beast: what are the 
realities of technical possiblity for my needs?
Do I need color displays?  Long lasting power 
supply, or just a plug with no BRICK?  Sound?
Speed?  Memory, Hard Drive?  Serial or Parallel?
 
While sift all your comments, it seemed very clear 
to me that we all have different needs and
perspectives on what best constitutes and Ami 
laptop.  I propose, that for those of us 
interested in developing the beast, we give some
time to discussion of central or common needs so 
that our efforts may be easily built upon by those 
of us with more specialized requisites.
 
That is enough of Why? for now.
 
 
THE EXISTENCE OF SUCH BEASTS
The Amiga portable has been in the world, probably
is now, and will be again.  My research (or more
appropriately, your contributed words) has given
the following 'sightings' of our quarry:
 
     -A1000 portable hack.  I've heard rumors of a
      plan, and one respondant apparently made 
      one.
 
     -A500 laptop/portable hack.  There are many
      reports of this animal.  I'm currently        
      trying to locate two individuals who have 
      made the attempt (uncertain of the 
      particulars of their success.
 
     -A600 MANY suggestions that this is the way
      to go.  Several individs indicate they are
      en route to hacking their A600s into
      portable form as we speak.  Rumors of a    
      diagramed hack.  One 600 portable spotted.
 
     -A1200 Many also suggest the 1200 to be the
      path to an Ami hack.  Not much else to 
      mention.
 
     -Commercial Portables  Sevral sightings and
      published words and images about these.  
      Apparently one was actually PRODUCED in 
      germany for a breif time (we suppose).  This
      beast was a laptop, with AC power supply and
      a monochrome screen.  Other sightings have    
      been made of American product(s) within
      various Amiga 'zines, both as advertisements
      and as product reviews.
 
     -C=64 portables were made and sold.  These 
chasses are apparently pertinent to laptop 
construction.
 
OK time for a little reality check on these 
puppies.  There are a number of characteristics 
surrounding the various hacks which are recurrent
and need pointing out.
     -About half of the reports talk about AC 
power supplies.  Batteries are also mentioned
but we'll discuss the problems in the HACKS 
section
     -About half of the hacked portables relied
on small screen portable TVs.  In other words the
portables were portable SYSTEMS where the chasses
of the various components had been reduced only.
     -There were very FEW (one in fact) reports of
color graphics used on an Amiga portable.
 
THE INVOLVEMENT OF COMMODORE
OK here's some of the really bad news.  According 
to several interviews with C= folks like Dave  
Haynie, Dave Pleasance and Lew Eggebrecht as well 
as information given to C= stockholders by C=,
there are absolutely NO plans for the development
of an Ami portable.  C=, well you know, we can
all say good and bad things about this company.
They seem resolute on this one.  Apparently legal
action, or its threat was used to leverage other
firms who tried to develop and market a third 
party laptop Amiga clone.  For those of you who 
are stockholders, and those of you who can  
organise, you can decide for yourselves if C=
can or should provide a laptop.  I believe
however, that for the short term, WE are going
to have to provide any laptop.
 
 
THE HACKS
That's really how this whole thing got started
right?  So why doesn't she shut up and get on 
with it.  Ok we know the beasties exist, and 
more are on the way.  As mentioned previously
there are problems and conditions (aren't there
always?) which we'll deal with before we talk  
about what IS being done and what WILL be done.
 
Hurdles
The problem which many kind people have reiterated
over and over again: Whoooeee!  That Suckers a 
fat Juice HOG!  Well she IS called the FAT Agnus
...te hee.  Ahem.  Seems to me there's a couple 
of issues here:
   -What chipset suck more juice?  Words like CMOS
NMOS and TTL get bandied about.  OK get the specs
and find out what the power reqs are for each, so
we can see where we need to build our power base 
from.
   -What machine sucks more juice?  We're  
fortunate to have several versions of the same
thing to play with, that is, the As 500, 600,
1000, 1200 and CDTV are roughly withing the 
same computing ballpark (yes I KNOW which one
I'd rather have, and which one I rather not).
So which of the Doggesses is the best suited in 
terms of low power consumption?
   -Peripherals.  This is a large topic.  Ideally
we'll find some LCD solution to the monitor issue,
but for some, the portably TV is an answer.  
Unfortunately these also take up the juice.  
Another issue are the floppies, hard drives and 
video toasters we're all going to need.  Those  
babies suck it up.
   -Battery technology will need to be on the
cutting for our beasts.  Several individs maintain
that video-cam equipment often uses heavy duty
cells designed for sustained loads.  Which one is 
best.  Alternately, what about an integrated AC 
adaptor for those who want portable to mean 
transportable?
I guess the gist of my point here is that laptop
construction is going to require extreme care
and consideration for power.  We'll hear much more 
about this.
 
Another set of hurdles for hacks is functionality.
What level of performance are we going to get for
our little beastie?
   -Displays are going to be tough.  For some, a
simple monochorme LCD (oh heck...LED) would do 
the trick as far as their applications were
concerned.  For others, a 256 grey scale would 
work.  Then  there are those of us who want, who
need 1088x1088 16.8 Million colors on the screen
at once for their workbench screen (snrk).  From
what you've all said so far, there are two paths.
   -The first is the portable TV, not too much 
needs to be said although if anyone could provide
specs on weight,power consumption quality, etc. 
that'd be just fine.
   -The second would of course be some kind of LCD
display.  Not too many seem exactly sure as to the
precise KIND of LCD, nor of exactly HOW to 
interface it.  The most coherent notion we seem to 
have at the moment is the gre-pc Color VGA display
from IBM which apparently is an LCD emmulation of
a standard VGA monitor.  This sounds pretty good
especially since I understand that all the screen
modes available to, say the ECS (PAL AND NTSC) are
displayable by a VGA monitor.  Also we may have
someone who can order these things in bulk.
 
Another peripheral question would be that of the 
keyboard and mouse.  I'm totally clueless about  
this one and could use some enlightening.  Some
have suggested that a C=64 joystick can be 
effectively implemented via joymouse to replace
the rat.  What can anyone say about small
powerbook-type trackballs?  We are really going to 
need to find some way to deal with the keyboard 
also.  Or are we?  What do you all think?
 
Oh goodness it's getting late!  Well one last 
thought on this section before I get to bed.  What
can anyone say about the use of a CDTV for a hack?
I've heard it's more a more compact motherboard 
than the A500, and that it consumes less power.
Whatch y'all know 'bout dat?
 
Current Projects
It appears that a number of individs are keen on 
hacking an Ami laptop presently.  I've tried to
note the most pertinant hurdles they are 
encountering.  I will also mention that the
majority of them seem to be focussed on the 
A600 as the Amiga to train to heel.  I've 
also mentioned that a good basic setup which
reflects the meeting of many common needs would
be an excellent step toward the creation of a
public Ami portable hack.
 
I propose, as a general goal and with an open,
invitation for discussion, that the creation of
an A600 laptop portable, with and LCD display
(color? grey scale?), FD and HD?,serial, disk,
video and parallel ports integral controller 
interface (whatever replaces the rat and 
keyboard), and some form of unintrusive power 
supply (no BRICK, no marine ship batteries)
should be a reasonable goal to aim for; we may
fall short of it, or be pleasantly surprised at
the results.
 
 
THE FUTURE
Well who can say?  I for one will continue to 
provide facillitation for this topic as long as
there are people on the net who want to 
participate.  I will certainly continue to
provide compiled information and act as a relay
for those wanting to follow this material closely.
I certainly hope that we can together create some 
kind of collective effort which results in what 
would be called, to some extent, by everyone, 
success.  And who knows, maybe when C= makes its 
next big shift in production, it'll include a
state of the art laptop Amiga (which those of us
with little in the way of financial resources can
drool over longingly as we write poetry on our
A37000 laptop hacks  ;}  )
 
 
Always open to your comments, insights advice and
whatever.  
 
Alexis
myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu
 






From myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu Mon Feb  7 10:18:12 1994
Received: from nak.berkeley.edu (nak.Berkeley.EDU [128.32.136.21]) by CSOS.ORST.EDU (8.6.4/8.6.4) with ESMTP id KAA18113 for <ridgwad@csos.orst.edu>; Mon, 7 Feb 1994 10:18:08 -0800
Received: from uclink.berkeley.edu by nak.berkeley.edu (8.6.4/1.40)
	id KAA04892; Mon, 7 Feb 1994 10:18:07 -0800
Received: from localhost by uclink.berkeley.edu (8.6.4/1.33(web)-oc3)
	id KAA26058; Mon, 7 Feb 1994 10:11:19 -0800
Date: Mon, 7 Feb 1994 10:11:18 -0800 (PST)
From: Alexis David Dinno <myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu>
Subject: Amiga Laptop Report #2 (fwd)
To: Dean Ridgwad <ridgwad@csos.orst.edu>
Message-ID: <Pine.3.89.9402071050.B25698-0100000@uclink.berkeley.edu>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII
Status: R




 
disclaimer:You KNOW that ANYONE can be misinformed.  Open your
door to a good day, but be prepared for a bad one.  Don't sue
me.
 
 
Amiga Laptop Quest Report II
 
Hello there oh ye faithful!
thanks for all your interest and contributions which have made
this quest possible.  I would like to start this report with an
announcement.  The Developers' list which I alluded to in the 
last report is now a reality.  This list is for those 
interested in actually creating a set of laptop hacks.  Any who
wish to join can e-mail me expressing you desire to do so.  
Hopefully we'll have a working set of hacks to spread all over 
creation in short order.
 
The undertaking of this project initially started on bulletin 
boards local to the Amiga's birth place in the San Francisco Bay
Area for the purpose of turning my A500 into a laptop portable 
(I recently upgraded to an A3000).  I hopped onto the internet 
and discovered a wealth of interest from many people in issues
relevant to our Holy Grail: the laptop Ami.  The recent shape of
my efforts has been directed toward the larger question of ANY
Ami laptop.
 
This time around, we'll discuss the following:
 
     -Amiga Laptop Advocacy
     -Sightings
     -Development Report (proto)
     -The Hacks
 
You all would not believe the ammount of crap I had to sift
through when ASCII dumping from the likes of 
comp.sys.amiga.hardware to my text editor.  The sheer ammount 
of info has been enourmous (and much appreciated lest I appear
ingracious).  In order to facilitate the edification of the Ami
SIG, I will be posting and mailing only this highly edited file
(and ones like it in the future).  However, I will be making 
the net, mail, and board transcripts available on request.  
This is so that we can focus directly on the most pertinant
information and progress toward the general accessability of 
laptop Ami's for those who so desire them.
 
Fast, and open communication has been the key to this quest's
initial success.  I will continue to provide e-mail updates for
those who wish to contact me via e-mail at:
 
myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu
 
Alright on to the report.
 
 
Advocacy:
 
     Well this time around, the advocacy forum seemed to focus
on two issues: Should C= make an Ami laptop/portable?  And WHY
Ami laptop portable?
     Let's start with C= hmmm?  Should C= or Shouldn't C=?  That
is the question...well most people in this discussion seemed 
to feel some need for an Ami laptop/portable, but few actually
directly suggested that C= produce it.  The first point for C='s
investment in a laptop seemed to be the recognition factor.  A
large number of uses for multi-media were touted, from field
sales, to portable demos.  Other uses, and users, of an Ami 
laptop were mentioned.  The point being that a laptop Ami is 
going to visit the real world, and that means Name Recognition
for C= et al.  Everyone reading this knows C='s US marketing is
the pits (despite the fact that C= has sold between 1/2 to 1/3
the number of PC units as Apple this year which is a damn sight
better than the past, although this does reflect more of a slump
 Apple's market share), Ami laptop would generate some
significant product recognition in the States, which we'd all
love.  I'm not too sure about Europe (where Ami is number 2, last
time I looked at stats, and Apple doesn't even count).  
     The other point made in the case for C= to produce an Ami
laptop is stereotyping.  Yes, Ami IS fantastic for multi-media
and desktop-video.  BUT, there are a number of functions which 
Ami performs just as well, if not better than other platforms, 
and getting Ami out there in public doing it will foster an Ami
positive environment for developers and for users.  I mean, I 
haven't seen the Mac DTP program which I prefer to Page Stream,
nor have I seen the Mac sequencer which I prefer to Music-X (my
own humble personal oppinions, flames not welcome), yet the Mac
is "KNOWN" to be the "BEST" platform for these types of
applications.  Amiga recognition via laptop would do a great
deal toward creating some elbow room for Amigites among the rest
of the PC world; YES you have some valid choices, and NO you
don't have to maintain a patheticly hostile and defensive stance
by trashing the other platforms available.
     There was basically one point with variants for C= not to
produce a laptop in the near future.  On a simple level it boils
down to C= just can't hack it right now.  Not that Ami laptop
couldn't be created, but C= is having enough trouble trying to
allocate its resources efficiently among its incredibly
successful 1200 and CD32.  The drain imposed by the creation of
Ami laptop would take too much from the development of AAA, the
5000 and the sustenance of C= in general.  Some have noted
technically, that the cost of such a machine (assuming it was
about on par with the 1200) would run into the unaffordable and
uncompetitive (a comment we've all been hearing much of late by
way of comparing the costs of PeeCees, Macs and Amigas, I
think).  The notion that C= has its hands full at the moment
seems to be widely regarded.
     Which leads to asking "Assuming some third party can
develop the Ami laptop, why have it anyway?"
     Well, we've already talked about the visibility factor. 
We've mentioned multi-media.  We've heard my tirade about
stereotyping.  We can all accept that there are a vast range of
legitimate uses of the Amiga.  The issue then seems a question
of general laptop legitimacy.  Some feel no need for $2000
gameboys (well gosh what Else is there to life?).  Others, like
myself, find a nice integration of my Amiga with many my lifes
activities, and would like to make such integration more
seamless, by removing the physical impediments imposed by
lugging 75 pounds of machine around.  Really, some would find
the laptop amusing, helpful, practical or a solution in many
senses and not necessarily in that order.  Others would find it
useless, except as a plaything or status symbol for "yuppie
scum."  But then that's why we're trying to develop these hacks
anyway...
 
 
Sightings:
 
     Well on the commercial side of our quest we've found some
dissapointing news.  The US company rumored to have designed, if
not actually produced, an Ami laptop has been reported by 
several individs as Newer Technologies, a third party Macintosh
developer.  According to one source, who apparently interviewed
the engineer heading the Ami laptop project (one Mr Pete Estes)
"They never (at the time they were advertising) had a working 
prototype, and they were pulled from a Toronto WOA show because
they were trying to pass off a mockup connected to an Amiga
hidden in the display as a working laptop."  However another
individ has claimed "They completed 1 prototype, before they 
were stopped by Commodore.  Their initial release would have 
been a 68000, [an '030] version was going to be available."  No
one has been able to produce a mailing address or phone for the 
company which is rumored to be located in Topeka, Kansas.
     Another sighting (of dubious merit) has apparently occurred
in the UK courtesy of some unnamed British Amiga magazines. 
Allegedly, advertisements of a C= laptop (complete with photos)
have surfaced.  This, of course, would contradict what C= has
announced to its stockholders.  As would similar reports from
German Amiga rags...
     Reports from Ami laptop home micro-breweries are
encouraging.  A number of people have brought forth accounts of
their personal hacks and the hacks of their acquaintances. 
Unfortunately, no one has produced a non-miniTV solution for the
portable, however one individ is using a text-only LCD run out
of the parallel port with some success.  Currently, the
development project is working towards a color VGA LCD solution
to display.  Another discouraging (perhaps) note concerning the
laptop portable quest, is the overwhelming indication of AC
adaptors being used, instead of batteries, although one of the
developers has reported a battery solution, and should be
forthcoming.
 
 
Development Report:
 
     Okay, there's really not too much say here as we've only 
just got started.  In the future this section will keep you 
informed on the progress we are making regarding particular 
technical aspects of Amiga hacking.  This section will also 
serve to ask you all for any pertinent information you might 
supply.  For example, the developers are currently looking for 
hard specs on any color VGA LCD which has a standard VGA 
interface.  We are especially interested in manufacturers,
price and part numbers if available.
     One thing more, the developers are trying to create some 
set of hacks for the Amiga community, if you feel you have any 
information or insights to contribute (aside from telling us for
gazillionth time that the chipset uses too much power ;} ), 
please contact me at:
myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu 
 
 
THE HACKS
 
     Sorry to dissapoint you who've read all this way with the 
expectation of glorious knowledge found...But we've only got one 
documented hack (A500) so far, and it needs a bit of cleaning up 
before we publish it.  Patience til next time; I'm one woman and 
can only get so much done.
 
 
Always open to your comments, insights advice and whatever.  
 
Alexis
myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu
 
 
Next report out around March 1st 1994
 
 
 
 
 



From myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu Wed Mar  2 15:05:37 1994
Received: from nak.berkeley.edu (nak.Berkeley.EDU [128.32.136.21]) by CSOS.ORST.EDU (8.6.5/8.6.4) with ESMTP id PAA21214 for <ridgwad@csos.orst.edu>; Wed, 2 Mar 1994 15:04:09 -0800
Received: from uclink.berkeley.edu by nak.berkeley.edu (8.6.4/1.40)
	id PAA29532; Wed, 2 Mar 1994 15:01:32 -0800
Received: from localhost by uclink.berkeley.edu (8.6.4/1.33(web)-oc3)
	id OAA04581; Wed, 2 Mar 1994 14:53:25 -0800
Date: Wed, 2 Mar 1994 14:53:23 -0800 (PST)
From: Alexis David Dinno <myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu>
Subject: Amiga Laptop Quest Report #3
To: Amiga Laptop Report Subscribers -- Phillip Garrow <pgarrow@student.umass.edu>,
        Brian Lee <blee@media.mit.edu>,
        Paul Liss <Paul.Liss@lambada.oit.unc.edu>,
        Taufik <EMWaves@cup.portal.com>, Dan Griffin <griffin@egr.msu.edu>,
        Andy Shelley <ccastas@prism.gatech.edu>,
        Edward Yee <zaphod@illuminati.io.com>,
        Dean Ridgwad <ridgwad@csos.orst.edu>,
        Tom Lanhaus <TOM_LANHAUS@fcircus.sat.tx.us>,
        Suras Gulrajanai <suraj@NWG.nectec.or.th>,
        Mark Riederer <riederer@acs.bu.edu>,
        Chris Darnell <cdarnell@csugrad.cs.vt.edu>,
        Ken Santiago <ksanti@sura.net>, greg <greg@sisters.cs.uoregon.edu>,
        jordan <jordan@dwarf.apana.org.au>, jsevinsk <jsevinsk@spd.dsccc.com>,
        grover <grover@cyber.net>, eriechel <eriechel@burner.com>,
        wicke <wicke@wpts0.physik.uni-wuppertal.de>,
        zsolizso <zsolizso@btk.jpte.hu>, kleca <kleca@ctc.com>,
        ao443 <ao443@freenet.carleton.ca>,
        Peter Phillips <yku50971@cawc.yoruku.ca>, wilks <wilks@lbm.com>,
        bliss <bliss@terapin.com>, Skyfox <skyfox@bgbbs.com>,
        morgan <morgan@krynn.augs.se>, kd <kd@master.uwyo.edu>,
        keithburns <keithburns@BIX.com>, Jiadar <JIADAR@delphi.com>,
        spoon <spoon@cwis.unomaha.edu>,
        "I.T.Dearing-SE2" <I.T.Dearing-SE2@computer-science.birmingham.ac.uk>,
        AMF <AMF@stud.hsn.no>, Andrew Pettifer <rxtajp@minyos.xx.rmit.EDU.AU>,
        Jamie Krutz <jkrutz@meta.burner.com>,
        Graham McLeod <graham@infosys.uct.ac.za>,
        Ahmad Badr <abadr@cup.portal.com>, Jardar <leidar@nvg.unit.no>,
        steve <stlombo@hermes.acm.rpi.edu>, idr <idr@cs.pdx.edu>,
        richard <rfoy@netcom.com>, Christopher <cd27+@andrew.cmu.edu>,
        wintermute <wintermute@xmission.com>, Thomas <leavitt@armory.com>,
        Nathan Morse <nmorse@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu>,
        Teemu <tylielsi@paju.oulu.fi>, Chris <ag592@yfn.ysu.edu>,
        Ryan <ryan@chaos.mcs.mu.edu>, Calum <tsangc@io.org>,
        Dave <davew@creative.demon.co.uk>,
        Joseph <t920747@minyos.xx.rmit.EDU.AU>, Roger <roger@daneel.augs.se>,
        Fred <Scheif@cup.portal.com>, Tedd <t.hill13@genie.geis.com>,
        Gus <gzader@muselab.ac.runet.edu>,
        Brian Ernst <nuked@eskinews.eskimo.com>, Dana <dcanfiel@indiana.edu>,
        Roger Anderson <roger@daneel.augs.se>,
        Jonathan Dinerstein <SLKDS@cc.usu.edu>,
        Rodger Ang <rang@laputa.ics.uci.edu>
Message-ID: <Pine.3.89.9403021428.A3545-0100000@uclink.berkeley.edu>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII
Status: R



Disclaimer: Never trust what anyone tells you, and trust what
your senses tell you only for the moment.  You know that Anyone
is capable of lying and being misinformed.  Don't sue me.
 
 
Amiga Laptop Quest Report III
 
     Howdy all.  This report will be a slim one and focus on
some rather eclectic issues pertaining to laptop development.  I
don't really have anything to report on this time other than the
progress made in the Developers' Group.  This seems to be due
mainly to the end of discussion about the prized Amiga
laptop/portable.
 
OK, this time around I'm going to talk about three things:
 
     -Display Reality
     -Development Projects
     -A Tenative Hack
 
 
Display Reality
 
     This is the hot question right?  I mean are we going to be
able to take advantage of our 24-bit graphic board/toaster setup
on our laptop/portable's display (leaving aside power
requirements)?  In a word: no.  I've spent a good deal of time
sniffing after luke-warm trails of color LCD displays since the
last report.  I've also done some amount of library research. 
Frankly, the production technology, as well as the actual LCD
technology isn't quite there yet.
     For those of you who aren't aware of how LCDs are made, I
offer the following illumination (any EEs may feel free to
correct any mistakes I make).  Color LCD displays rely on Active
Matrix technology.  This sort of LCD is different from the ones
we're all familiar with in our calculators and wristwatches. 
Active Matrix LCDs essentially have a circuit (transistor) for
each pixel on the screen.  This has two repercussions.  First,
Active Matrix LCDs draw more juice than passive LCDs.  Second,
and more importantly, EACH transistor has to be placed
accurately and function properly.  The consequence of a failed
transistor is called a Stuck Pixel.  Stuck pixels on a grey
scale LCD may range in their visible effect from a dark pixel
(one which never lights up) to a pixel which is always on.  On a
color LCD display, the effects are much more noticeable: "Hey!
How come that red spot won't go away?"  This can be quite
annoying.  The trouble with producing color Active Matrix
displays, is that you need Three transistors per pixel: one each
for red, green and blue.  This creates two problems.  First the
probability of having a stuck pixel is tripled due to the number
of transistors needed being tripled.  Second, the probability of
having a stuck pixel is further increased because the
transistors need to be packed much more tightly together.  The
result of this difficulty in error free production, is that up
until recently, a 50% quality fail rate was about average
(pretty good actually).  Recently some producers of color LCDs
have reported 45-35% fail rates.  This is VERY costly in terms
of production.  Furthermore, the production time on these things
is SLOW.  The major producers of color LCDs were making about
100 a month or less in 1992.  The production technology is
apparently improving however; NEC (which is attempting to become
THE premier producer of color LCD displays...but that's another
story) has claimed recently that they expect to be able to
produce color LCD displays in the thousands to tens of thousands
per month.  They also claim to have the unit price of color LCD
screens down to around $300-$500 by 1995.  The upshot of all
this is that unless you're willing to pay the $3,000.00 to
$15,000.00 (nope, those aren't typos) price for color LCD
displays at the current time, color for your Amiga
laptop/portable isn't very likely.
     OK a little bit about color LCDs themselves.  They're on
their way, as far as production is concerned.  As far as their
technical specs go they're nearly here already.  Most of the
specs I've seen for these devices talk about 640x480 pixel
display resolutions.  Not so good for PAL in interlace, but
close.  Some color LCD displays are limited in terms of the
number of colors they can display.  Some are limited to 250,
some to a few thousand, some to 250,000.  The price tends to
correspond.  There is also a promising trend toward analog (RGB)
interfaces.  While most of the units currently being produced
(as far as I can tell) are digitally driven (TTL), the future of
LCD monitors will boom in analog.  Or so some corporations
think.  Apparently, NEC feels that LCD displays will entirely
replace CRT displays due to comfort of use, and the lack of RF
interference from LCDs.  Therefore NEC is investing heavily into
analog LCD R&D.  The useability of these types of displays in
Amiga terms, will increase.
     On the other hand. B&W and grey-scale LCDs are pretty
common, and in some cases cheap (about $30).  The problem, is
the interface.  Most LCDs are driven by a digital signal. 
However, all Amigas generate digital signals (in addition to the
standard RGA analog) and the Developers' Group is currently
hacking the appropriate interfaces.
     B&W?  Grey-scale?  ...faces falling, hopeful smiles
wilting.  Yeah B&W.  Grey-scale.  Leaving aside the issue of
small screen TV displays.  The question people need to ask
themselves is this: what am I going to use a laptop Amiga for? 
Word-processing?  DTP?  Programming?  Music?  Terminal Apps? 
Most of the non-video/non-graphic apps work fine in B&W. 
Workbench certainly does.  If you don't believe me try playing
with a two color palette in your favorite apps (fer cryin out
loud, Page Stream is B&W...pretty much).  On the other hand,
games might be a problem.  Both in terms of color, and in terms
of custom screen formats which might not be compatible with the
LCD display (go buy a LYNX or Gameboy).  Video, graphics and
presentation apps might also suffer.  Those of you who've
diddled with your own hacks might want to start a discussion on
c.s.Amiga.hardware about the merits of small TVs and B&W, or
text-only (did I fail to mention that thois has been done?), or
grey-scale display experiences.
 
 
Developers' Group
 
     Well we've been getting along.  I'd like to thank in
particular Mike and Brian who've been putting a great deal of
effort into this project, particularly with regards to the
display issue.  Right now the Devs are working on a TTL
interface to drive a B&W display.  The upside to this particular
display solution, is that it should cost $60-$80 at the most
(that includes LCD and interface), and the parts are easily
found.  The next step would probably be working out a similar
hack for a 16 shade grey-scale LCD.
 
     I'm also doing some research into power supplies for those
interested in the stand alone laptop (yeah I know, the custom
chipset uses so much juice, that it would drain any battery in
about 41 seconds....we'll never get anywhere with that mindset). 
This research is taking three directions.  First, I've got a
source who knows his stuff about camcorder and camera battery
sytems.  There may be a simple solution right there.  One of the
Devs apparently has built a battery power supply, and plans will
be forthcoming.  I'm doing some CRAZY research into alternative
battery technology, particularly into the stand-alone flywheel
electromechanical batteries being produced this spring by
Honeywell (...what?).  Anyway, this busy student has lots of
research to do for her classes, so it may be a while before I
can work significantly on the power supply solution.
 
     Cases have been another point of research.  An industrial
design artist has offered insights into the creation of custom
cases.  Furthermore a number of you have found some laptop-case
solutions and shared them (please continue to do so!).  In fact,
one question I have is this: Are cases available as retail
units, or is finding one simply a matter of luck at your local
surplus/wasteland electronics store?  A number of people have
mentioned particular cases, but how would one go about acquiring
such things?  Any insights?  Another proposal has been the
modification of the existing Amiga case.  One of the Devs is
planning on creating a hinged fold-up display to attach to his
A600.  How about some well documented feedback about cases?
 
     Well that's about it for the Devs this month.  If you have
any information you think would be helpful, drop me a line via
e-mail.  If you are interested in working to help develop an Ami
laptop/portable drop me a line and tell me what you are or were
working on  or what you'd like to help/be helped with.
 
 
Hacks
 
     Well I promised I'd have an A500 hack ready for publishing
this month, but I don't.  Sorry.  However, I am reporting here
the rough sketch of an A500 hack offered by a member of the
Amiga community (really it's more of an account of a hack).  I'd
like to note that the goal of the Development project, is to
create a Well Documented set of detailed hacks, including
illustrations and step-by-step instructions hopefully.  The
following information is offered up as brain-fodder.  Perhaps it
may be useful to some of the more ingeneous among us for
creating a hack.  Perhaps it will serve to stir up new ideas.
 
     THE FOLLOWING IS INFORMATION IS OFFERED AS IS, WITH NO
ASSUMPTION OF LIABILITY FOR DAMAGE TO SELF OR PROPERTY RESULTING
FROM ITS ATTEMPTED IMPLEMENTATION.  (in other words, be careful
and know what your doing)
 
     I used the old Compaq "sewing machine" style case.
I slipped in an A500 motherboard (don't remember vers#).
Added an AddIDE for the 52 Meg HD (works great!),
and the Supra RX500 (?) ram board, with some hacks to make it
fit sideways in the case.  I created an I/O panel (for the right
side of the case, where there was just a ventilation grill
before) that has all the standard Amiga ports available, as well
as a new interface for an external RGB monitor (that's right--2
monitors at the same time.  handy for presentations!).
     Display is by a Sony 10" Trinitron RGB monitor that I
heavily reworked (made the contoller board 1/4 the previous
size).
     It uses the original Compaq power supply.
     I also modified the A500 keyboard so it would fit into the
portable keyboard case (involved cutting up the keyboard metal
and PCB, and glueing it back together in a different
configuration).
     The final touch was to make a number of Amiga logos, via
PostScript, and laminate them, and glue them into the logo spots
(sort of depressions in the plastic case) so that it looks more
or less professional.
 
Does anyone want to expand upon this and maybe rework it into
something more presentable?
 
 
Parting Words
 
     And so we come to the end of another exciting blah blah
blah.  No really, thank you all for your input.  The internet
has given us access to the great wealth of resources and
information that individuals possess, and allowed us to share
them.  If anyone has any questions, insights or criticisms,
please feel free to write me at:
 
                 myrtle@uclink.berkeley.edu
 
Warmest Regards,
 
Alexis
 
Next Report out around April 1st


